Definition
What is a monetary administrative penalty?
A monetary administrative penalty is a sum that Quebec's Commission d'accès à l'information can impose directly on a company, without going through a court, when it fails to meet certain obligations of the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector. For a company, the ceiling is $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover, whichever is higher.
What the law provides
Quebec's Law 25 rewrote the province's private-sector privacy act. It allows the Commission d'accès à l'information to impose a sum itself on a company that fails to meet some of its obligations.
The decision is made by a person the Commission designates. It requires no prior judgment. It follows a notice of non-compliance, which gives the company the opportunity to submit its observations. The Commission publishes the list of failures that can lead to a penalty, along with a general framework explaining how it applies this power.
The ceiling of $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover is a maximum. The amount of a penalty is decided case by case, under the Commission's framework.
The failures that touch marketing
Two of the failures the Commission names fall squarely within marketing work:
- Failing to adequately inform people of the collection of their personal information. A form that collects a name or an email without saying what they will be used for is the most common case.
- Failing to take the security measures needed to protect that information.
Visitor tracking is the other sensitive area. The law requires that people be informed in advance of a tool's profiling functions (which most advertising cookies perform) and that those functions stay inactive until the person turns them on. A technique that restores tracking despite a refusal can expose the company to a penalty.
Administrative penalty or penal proceedings
The Commission has two separate routes. The monetary administrative penalty is a decision by the Commission itself. Penal proceedings, which the Commission can also bring, lead to a fine set by law: from $15,000 to $25 million or 4% of worldwide turnover, whichever is higher. That fine is doubled for a repeat offence.
The first does not go through a court. The second leads to markedly heavier fines. The choice between them belongs to the Commission.
The undertaking that removes the penalty
The law provides a way out. A company can undertake to the Commission to take the measures needed to remedy a failure or mitigate its consequences. If the undertaking is approved and then honoured, no administrative penalty can be imposed for the acts observed.
The undertaking can carry conditions, up to an obligation to pay a sum. A correction effort that is under way and documented therefore carries more weight than an empty file. What to propose to the Commission, and how to word it, is something to decide with legal counsel.
Take two fictional companies. The first has worldwide turnover of $20 million: 2% comes to $400,000, less than $10 million. Its ceiling is therefore $10 million, the higher of the two amounts.
The second has turnover of $900 million: 2% comes to $18 million, more than $10 million. Its ceiling is therefore $18 million. In both cases, the figure is a maximum: it does not tell you what a penalty would actually amount to.
We read the monetary administrative penalty as the reason to deal early with the three places where the law touches marketing: the form, the tracking cookie and the email list. The form is the most common point, and fixing it takes a few hours. Consent for measurement tools is the most technical: implemented poorly, it can also skew your numbers and the budget decisions that follow from them.
We can take on the inventory of forms and tools that receive data, the rewrite of collection notices, the consent implementation and the check that measurement still holds afterwards. The decision about information you already hold, the appointment of the person in charge and the legal validation stay with you. Falia is not a law firm, and this entry is not legal advice.
Not to be confused with
- Penal proceedings
- Penal proceedings lead to a fine set by law, from $15,000 to $25 million or 4% of worldwide turnover, doubled for a repeat offence. The monetary administrative penalty is imposed by the Commission itself, without a court, and its ceiling is lower.
- Consent gap
- The consent gap is an effect on measurement: the conversions your platforms no longer see when a visitor refuses cookies. Trying to close it by working around the refusal is precisely what can expose a company to an administrative penalty.
- Onus of proving consent
- The onus of proving consent comes from Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), a federal law that governs commercial email. The monetary administrative penalty described here falls under Quebec's privacy law: both regimes apply at the same time.
Related concepts
Further reading
- Quebec Law 25 and marketing: forms, cookies and email lists
- Consent and measurement: understanding Google Consent Mode's limits
- B2B websites in Quebec: three issues to plan for
- CASL and newsletters: consent, identification and unsubscribing
- AI usage policy for small businesses: what should it include?
Related services
Frequently asked questions
Can a small business really be penalized?
Yes. The law does not reserve administrative penalties for large companies. The ceiling of $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover is a maximum: the Commission sets the amount case by case, under the enforcement framework it publishes.
Does a penalty require going before a judge?
No. The penalty is decided by a person the Commission designates, without a prior judgment. It follows a notice of non-compliance that gives you the opportunity to submit your observations. The remedies available against a decision are something to check with legal counsel.
What can a company do to avoid a penalty?
The law allows a company to undertake to the Commission to remedy the failure. If the undertaking is approved and then honoured, no administrative penalty can be imposed for the acts observed. Fixing your forms and your cookie consent first remains the simplest way to reduce the risk.